User blog comment:SethAllred343/Survivor 5/@comment-3098613-20110218215841/@comment-2186558-20110218224634

Well, think of it like this:

There were only two returnees allowed in, and with the fact that they went more in depth with what happened since the season they were last in, they beat you out. Trey, for the most part, would only work with Rachel, so his chances got reduced, and since it didn't explain anything about Trey's personality, he wasn't allowed in.